Target Curves Compared

Last updated

Start Here

Guides

Resources

Five curves come up again and again in Dirac Live discussions. Here they are on one graph, drawn from the actual curve files, with what each is for.

The five popular curves drawn from their files. Where a file stops at a frequency limit, the line stops too.
The five popular curves drawn from their files. Where a file stops at a frequency limit, the line stops too.

Jump to: Beginner Advanced

Which curve should you try?

Beginner

CurveBassTrebleDirac describes it asTry it if
Harman (+4, +6, +8 dB)Lifted by 4, 6 or 8 dB below about 40 Hz, back to 0 dB by 400 HzFlatPunchy and dynamicYou want films and modern music with weight and impact
NADPeaks at about +6.6 dB around 30 Hz, then falls away steeply below 20 HzFalls to about -4.4 dB at 18 kHzWarm and envelopingYou mainly listen to stereo music and want warmth over slam
Audio Advice (+3, +4, +5 dB)Lifted by 3, 4 or 5 dB below about 35 HzFalls gently to -1.5 dBA middle ground for mixed useFlat sounds dull but Harman feels too heavy
StormAudio cinemaAbout +4.6 dB from 30 to 80 Hz, rolling off below 30 HzFalls to about -5.5 dBA cinema sound without fatigue at high volumeYou have a dedicated cinema room and play loud
Flat0 dB throughout0 dB throughoutAnalytical and revealingYou want a reference to compare against

The bass and treble figures above are read from the curve files themselves. The descriptions are Dirac’s.

A simple way to choose

  • Films first: start with Harman +6 dB.
  • Music first: start with NAD or Audio Advice +4 dB.
  • Dedicated cinema room: try the StormAudio set, one curve for each speaker type.
  • Export two curves to two slots and switch between them on the same film or album.

Get the files on the downloads page.

Figures come from the curve files, descriptions from Dirac’s target curve guide.


Reading the differences

Advanced

  • The Harman and Audio Advice sets differ mainly in how much bass they add. Above a few hundred hertz each set is identical, so switching within a set only changes the bass.
  • The Harman files stay flat above 400 Hz. Audio Advice adds a gentle treble roll-off from about 2 kHz. NAD and StormAudio roll off more.
  • The NAD file has a steep drop below 20 Hz built in, so it won’t ask the subwoofers for deep infrasonic output.
  • The StormAudio set is three curves: left, centre and right; surrounds; and subwoofers (30 to 140 Hz only). The surround curve sits slightly higher through the midrange than the LCR curve.
StormAudio's three cinema curves. The subwoofer curve only covers 30 to 140 Hz.
StormAudio’s three cinema curves. The subwoofer curve only covers 30 to 140 Hz.

How we drew the graphs: each line joins the breakpoints stored in the file on a log frequency scale. Dirac Live may draw the curve more smoothly between points. The StormAudio files start at 0 Hz, which a log scale can’t show, so those lines begin at their first point near 30 Hz.

Sources